← Take Up Dance-Fitness · Module 7 of 11 · 8 minutes
How to tell a genuine instructor from a performer in costume
Why this lesson is here
Interest in exercise is high, and some performers present themselves as fitness instructors because it is a way to reach an audience. Most of them mean no harm. But a class run by someone with no qualification, insurance or licence can hurt people, and a class that feels like a performance can put newcomers off exercise. This lesson helps you tell the difference before you join.
Two words worth knowing
- Virtue signalling is using talk about good values to improve your reputation. In everyday use it often suggests the speaker does not mean it, though philosophers define it by its purpose, not the speaker’s sincerity. In fitness it sounds like “inclusive”, “empowering”, “authentic” or “healthy” with no proof behind the words.
- Masquerading is presenting yourself as something you are not: an unqualified instructor, an “authentic” teacher of a tradition you have not learned, or a licensed class with an unlicensed playlist.
We found no study that measures how common this is, so we do not give a number. Words are cheap. Proof is not.
A 60-second check
- Qualification: can you see the instructor’s qualification, its level and who awarded it? Qualifications and insurance should be easy to find.
- Insurance: do they hold public liability insurance? The Register of Exercise Professionals (REPs) requires at least £2 million of civil liability cover.
- A public register: on the REPs register, certificates are checked directly with the awarding organisations, and an instructor is shown as suspended if insurance or required training lapses. Check the status, not the profile text, because bios are written by the instructor.
- First aid and safeguarding: ask if they hold a current first aid certificate and, if children attend, safeguarding checks.
- Music: ask whether the class is licensed for the music it plays (see Reporting malpractice, in Course 4).
- Honest claims: be careful with guarantees such as “10kg in 8 weeks”, pressure to pay upfront, a vague claim to cover everything, or avoiding being checked. REPs lists all of these as warning signs.
Instructor or performer?
This comparison is Pungra’s own, not a published test. Many people are both, and performing is not wrong. What matters is which comes first in a fitness class.
- Who is it for? An instructor teaches the people in the room. A performer plays to the camera or the audience.
- Safety: an instructor warms up, explains, offers easier and harder options and watches the room. A performer may skip all of that.
- Who can join? An instructor makes it possible for beginners to take part. A performer’s routine often assumes you can already do it.
- Proof: an instructor shows qualification, insurance and licence. A performer shows follower counts.
- The test: would the class still be worth doing if nobody watched?
Why the checking matters
In 2007 REPs reported that several instructors had tried to forge qualification certificates, and its registrar warned that forgery could put the public at risk through false claims of qualification or a lack of suitable insurance. The same concern is now written into rules elsewhere. In India, where hundreds of millions of people watch fitness content online, the government’s consumer affairs department issued guidelines in 2023 requiring health experts to disclose their certifications, and in 2025 the advertising standards body began requiring relevant qualifications, stated upfront, for health claims about prevention, treatment or cure.
REPs registration is voluntary as far as we could find, and the REPs page does not say it is legally required, so an instructor who is not on the register is a question to ask, not proof of wrongdoing. There are many good instructors who are not on it. If you think someone is making false claims or playing unlicensed music, Reporting malpractice, in Course 4, explains how to report it.
Sources and further reading
- REPs: How the REPs public register works: certificates verified with awarding organisations, at least £2 million civil liability cover, First Aid at Work, CPD, suspension when insurance expires, and self-reported bios.
- REPs: Red flags when hiring a personal trainer: no public proof of qualification, guaranteed results, pressure to pay upfront, vague specialism and avoiding registers.
- Health Club Management (3 October 2007): Qualification forgers face punishment: instructors forging certificates and the REPs registrar's warning about risk to the public.
- Westra (2021): Virtue Signaling and Moral Progress (Philosophy & Public Affairs): virtue signalling defined as using moral talk to enhance one's moral reputation, without requiring insincerity.
- Tosi and Warmke (2016): Moral Grandstanding (Philosophy & Public Affairs): moral grandstanding defined as the use of public discourse for moral self-promotion.
- Mondaq: ASCI update to influencer guidelines, qualifications mandatory for health, nutrition and finance claims (April 2025): qualification and upfront disclosure for health and nutrition claims about prevention, treatment or cure.
- ThePrint: Disclosure or disclaimer must for celebrities and influencers endorsing as health experts (10 August 2023): Indian Department of Consumer Affairs guidelines requiring certifications to be disclosed.
- DataReportal: Digital 2026, India: about 1.03 billion internet users and advertising reach on YouTube, Instagram and Facebook (late 2025 estimates, not unique users).
- Citizens Advice: Reporting to Trading Standards (England): how reports reach Trading Standards, what they can and cannot do for you, and the weekend online form hours (the page shows a review date of 11 November 2019, so check it is still current).
- Advertising Standards Authority: Make a complaint: what the ASA covers (including websites and a company's own social media), how to complain, and that it does not accept anonymous or emailed complaints.
Evidence notes: The 60-second check is built from the REPs register page and its red-flags page. The instructor-or-performer comparison is Pungra's own, not a published test. We found no study measuring how common masquerading is. REPs registration is voluntary as far as we could find, REPs bios are self-reported, and the Indian rules are summarised from law-firm and news reports, not legal advice. The forgery report is from 2007. Last checked 7 November 2026. Links open in a new tab, and some sites may ask you to accept cookies or sign in.